Planning a Mexican Caribbean getaway this fall, but you’re already taken aback by reports of crowds in Playa this September (even though it’s the off-season), or Tulum’s incessant, week-round party scene?
Long gone are the days when Mexico in the fall was synonymous with a more relaxed atmosphere.
As we reported previously, the sunny hotspot is now jam-packed with beach bums and bachelor event-goers, and this has led peace-seekers to wonder:
Is there any place in the confines of the Yucatán Peninsula that remains laid-back and calm, and where you can still find white sands and clear seas?
We’re not sure about you, but we’re going with the expert advice on this one, and according to the Cancun Sun, the leading English-speaking authority on all things Mexican Caribbean, the region’s prime autumnal destination is Isla Mujeres:
Unspoiled Paradise A Short Boat Ride Away From Cancun
Lying a mere 13 miles across from Cancun, this small island, about half a mile across and five miles long, may be a stone’s throw away from the busiest resort dump in the Western Hemisphere, but you’d be surprised by how far-removed it feels.
As the Cancun Sun put it, Isla Mujeres is the ‘ultimate September escape just minutes from (Cancun’s) Hotel Zone’, and that’s a party due to the higher degree of exclusivity you get here.
Take the room availability, for instance: Isla Mujeres is a tiny landmass, and there’s only so many luxury all-inclusive resorts you can fit within it. According to Booking.com, there are only 46 hotels listed on the island (excluding guesthouses and B&Bs) as of September 2025.
For comparison purposes, Cancun has an additional 100 hotel listings.
How Much Do Hotels Cost In Isla Mujeres?
When you narrow it down to 4-star hotels, and then you zoom in further on the best-rated at the cheapest price, the top property on Booking is Casa Alkimia Town, an elegant boutique hotel with a rustic touch, only a few steps away from the trendy Playa Norte.
It has an exceptional average rate of 9.9 out of 10, based on 100 reviews (that’s the closest you get to universal acclaim, really), and believe it or not, it isn’t even that expensive.
If you think a private room with a balcony overlooking a mini jungle of palm trees, and the teal-colored Caribbean in the distance, will set you back $370–$400 per night, just know fall getaway deals may have increased in prices across the board, but Casa Alkimia is definitely an exception to the rule:
Overnights here start from $176 for 2 adults, or $88 each.
Where To Escape The Crowds In Isla Mujeres
Fewer hotels don’t necessarily translate into no crowds, and that’s certainly true for a number of Isla Mujeres in certain beaches, and at certain times of the day.
That being said, there’s truly only one beach in all of the island that bears the brunt of the Mexican Caribbean’s mass tourism, and that’s Playa Norte: as it is a short walk from the ferry terminal, it is where most Cancun day-trippers head for the day.
We couldn’t really blame them, as this beach is indeed gorgeous, with its powdered-sugar white sands and crystal-clear seas, known to be largely free of sargassum throughout the year, but Isla Mujeres’ charm lies in its undeveloped coast.
Playa Norte is already pretty ‘chill’ by Cancun standards, but if it’s unspoiled nature you’re looking for, Playa Indios is one of the least crowded beaches.
Located on the West coast, the coastal stretch that directly faces Cancun offers shallow, crystalline seas and a palm-shaded shoreline.
Even more offbeat, Playa Paraíso is perfect for sunbathing away from the overpriced beach bars, and just south of the world-famous Playa Norte, Playa Sol boasts a more intimate setting, warm waters, and equally beautiful, unruffled sands.
For those staying close to Centro, Playa Mujeres’ equivalent to a ‘main settlement’ or capital, Playa Centro is also an option. It has recently renewed its Blue Flag status for the 2025–2026 season, and it’s outstandingly clean and well-managed.
Last But Not Least… Limited Sargassum
Sargassum is a curse afflicting Mexican Caribbean-bound travelers for most of the year, and let’s face it, even when its levels go down, it’s never guaranteed it will go away completely.
Though it usually tapers in the fall, residue patches of the persistent, foul-smelling seaweed continue washing ashore on the mainland, but rarely ever on Isla Mujeres, especially along its North and West coast.
This means beaches like Norte and Centro, two of the most sought-after, see very little sargassum as the island’s surfboard shape helps protect its West-facing side from the algae.
After all, sargassum is dragged westward, and Cancun is the Westernmost point it can go around these ends.
Learn more about Isla Mujeres—and all its fascinating culture and beautiful nature—here.
Vinicius Costa
Vini, our senior lead writer at Travel Off Path, has over 60+ countries under his belt (and currently weaving tales from Paris!), and a knack for turning off-the-beaten-path experiences into informative stories that will have you packing your bags.
The Travel Off Path Advantage: Your Travel Toolkit
Subscribe To Our Latest Posts
Enter your email address to subscribe to Travel Off Path’s latest breaking travel news, straight to your inbox.
Please visit:
Our Sponsor
